Heat Waves in the United States: Mortality Risk during Heat Waves and Effect Modification by Heat Wave Characteristics in 43 U.S. Communities
G. Brooke Anderson1, Michelle L. Bell2
1 Environmental Engineering Program, and, 2 School of Forestry and Environmental Studies, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut, USA
Environ Health Perspect 119:210-218 (2011). http://dx.doi.org/10.1289/ehp.1002313 [online 18 November 2010]
Background: Devastating health effects from recent heat waves, and projected increases in frequency, duration, and severity of heat waves from climate change, highlight the importance of understanding health consequences of heat waves.
Objectives: We analyzed mortality risk for heat waves in 43 U.S. cities (1987–2005) and investigated how effects relate to heat waves’ intensity, duration, or timing in season.
Methods: Heat waves were defined as ≥ 2 days with temperature ≥ 95th percentile for the community for 1 May through 30 September. Heat waves were characterized by their intensity, duration, and timing in season. Within each community, we estimated mortality risk during each heat wave compared with non-heat wave days, controlling for potential confounders. We combined individual heat wave effect estimates using Bayesian hierarchical modeling to generate overall effects at the community, regional, and national levels. We estimated how heat wave mortality effects were modified by heat wave characteristics (intensity, duration, timing in season).
Results: Nationally, mortality increased 3.74% [95% posterior interval (PI), 2.29–5.22%] during heat waves compared with non-heat wave days. Heat wave mortality risk increased 2.49% for every 1°F increase in heat wave intensity and 0.38% for every 1-day increase in heat wave duration. Mortality increased 5.04% (95% PI, 3.06–7.06%) during the first heat wave of the summer versus 2.65% (95% PI, 1.14–4.18%) during later heat waves, compared with non-heat wave days. Heat wave mortality impacts and effect modification by heat wave characteristics were more pronounced in the Northeast and Midwest compared with the South.
Conclusions: We found higher mortality risk from heat waves that were more intense or longer, or those occurring earlier in summer. These findings have implications for decision makers and researchers estimating health effects from climate change.
Key words: climate change, extreme temperature events, heat waves, human health, mortality, temperature–mortality relationships
Address correspondence to M.L. Bell, 195 Prospect St., New Haven, CT 06511. Telephone: (203) 432-9869. Fax: (203) 436-9158. E-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org
This work was supported by a U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Science to Achieve Results graduate fellowship (91689201-0), a National Science Foundation graduate fellowship, the National Institute for Environmental Health Sciences (ES012054-03), and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency through the Johns Hopkins Particulate Matter Research Center (RD-83241701).
The authors declare they have no actual or potential competing financial interests.
Received 19 April 2010; accepted 07 October 2010; online 18 November 2010.
Heat waves can have large impacts on human health; mortality occasionally more than doubles during heat waves (e.g., Oechsli and Buechley 1970; Whitman et al. 1997). Interest in related health effects increased after major heat waves (i.e., Chicago, IL, 1995; Europe, 2003) (Le Tertre et al. 2006; Semenza et al. 1996) and with projections that climate change may increase the frequency, duration, and intensity of heat waves (Meehl and Tebaldi 2004). Understanding how heat waves affect health is key to preparing communities for heat waves and to estimating the health impacts of climate change.
Most studies of mortality and heat estimated health effects during specific heat waves (e.g., Kaiser et al. 2007; Weisskopf et al. 2002) or applied time-series or case-crossover methods to estimate the effects of single days of heat. Few studies combined approaches to consider the effects of both heat waves and single days of high temperature (Anderson and Bell 2009; Hajat et al. 2006); they showed additional health effects from prolonged heat beyond the sum of anticipated effects associated with single hot days. These studies, however, did not distinguish between effects of individual heat waves, but rather estimated health responses assuming that all heat waves of a specified definition have the same impact on health.
The study of heat waves faces several challenges. Heat waves are usually defined as extended periods of extreme heat, although no consistent definition exists regarding the temperature threshold, temperature metric, and number of days used to define heat waves. For example, studies have used thresholds of mean temperature (Hajat et al. 2006), apparent temperature (Smoyer 1998), or combinations of thresholds of apparent and minimum temperature (Robinson 2001; Weisskopf et al. 2002). Use of various heat wave definitions results in different time periods being classified as heat waves, hindering comparison and synthesis of results across studies. Further, heat waves differ in their intensity (degree of heat) and duration. Although most studies use measures of intensity and duration to define a heat wave, few have investigated how these heat wave characteristics affect the mortality impact.
Early studies of one or a few heat waves proposed that differences between the health effects of different heat waves might relate to a heat wave’s intensity, duration, or timing in the summer, although these studies did not investigate effect modification (e.g., Ellis et al. 1975; Schuman 1972). Research of heat waves in New York, New York (Marmor 1975); Madrid, Spain (Diaz et al. 2002); and St. Louis, Missouri (Smoyer 1998) found that mortality effects of heat waves decreased as summer progressed. Studies estimating other elements of the temperature–mortality relationship also found differences in effects with timing in season. Effects of single days of high temperature were larger earlier in the summer in several U.S. and European cities (e.g., Baccini et al. 2008; Hajat et al. 2002; Kalkstein and Smoyer 1993). A study in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, using a synoptic approach found that oppressive air masses had greater effects when they occurred earlier in the summer (Kalkstein et al. 1996). Of this research, only the single-city studies considered heat waves (i.e., extended periods of high temperature) (Diaz et al. 2002; Marmor 1975; Smoyer 1998).
Other studies provided evidence of the importance of heat wave duration and intensity. One international study showed that duration sometimes modified heat wave mortality effects (Kalkstein and Smoyer 1993). Studies of Madrid (Diaz et al. 2002) and St. Louis (Smoyer 1998) found greater mortality effects for longer heat waves. The duration and intensity of oppressive air masses sometimes modified their mortality effects (Kalkstein and Greene 1996; Kalkstein et al. 1996). Two studies found that average mortality effects increase when heat wave definitions are limited to longer or more intense heat waves (Anderson and Bell 2009; Hajat et al. 2006).
In this study, we estimated the mortality effects of heat waves across the United States (43 communities) for the period 1987–2005 and determined how these effects changed when heat waves were more intense, longer, or earlier in the summer. Although several studies have suggested that heat wave characteristics affect mortality risk, to our knowledge this is the first multicity study of prolonged periods of high temperature (heat waves) in the United States to investigate the impacts of heat wave timing and the largest to examine effect modification by heat wave duration and intensity. This research is also one of the largest studies to date of heat wave effects in the United States. We combined episodic and time-series approaches to estimate the risk of nonaccidental mortality during each individual heat wave compared with risk on non-heat wave days. Then we estimated whether heat wave intensity, duration, or timing in season explained variability in effect estimates. We examined regional differences in heat wave effects and in the modification of effects by heat wave characteristics.
Materials and Methods
Data and heat wave selection. Daily nonaccidental mortality data for 108 U.S. urban communities (1987–2005) were obtained from an extended version of the National Morbidity, Mortality, and Air Pollution Study data set (originally 1987–2000) (Anderson and Bell 2009; Internet-Based Health and Air Pollution Surveillance System 2005). Communities were defined as contiguous counties of a metropolitan area (Bell et al. 2004). We omitted data for noncontinental communities, those with population < 200,000 (Dominici et al. 2006; Peng et al. 2008), and those without weather data for ≥ 99.5% of study days, leaving 59 communities.
Weather data came from the National Climatic Data Center (2011). Daily relative humidity was calculated from dew point temperature (Bosen 1958) and used to calculate daily apparent temperature, a metric incorporating air temperature and relative humidity to better approximate the physical experience of heat (Robinson 2001). Dew point temperature is correlated with air temperature and was adjusted for daily mean temperature to limit collinearity in the model (after adjustment, average community correlation between daily dew point temperature and maximum temperature = 0.12) (Bell et al. 2004). We limited analysis to the warm season (1 May–30 September).
A heat wave consists of consecutive days with temperatures above a threshold temperature that can either be physiologically based (absolute threshold) or location based (relative threshold) (Robinson 2001). We used a relative threshold based on the community’s own long-term weather, to allow for regional acclimatization to temperatures normal for a community. We identified heat waves as ≥ 2 consecutive days with daily mean temperature (Tmean) higher than the community’s 95th percentile warm season Tmean (for 1987–2005), a definition similar to those used previously (Anderson and Bell 2009; Hajat et al. 2006).
Sixteen of the 59 communities had very mild summers (90th percentile summertime mean apparent temperature < 80°F). Under our heat wave definition, the threshold temperature for a heat wave was low in these communities (e.g., 67.3°F in San Francisco, CA). Even though such temperatures are rare for these communities, we did not categorize days with these low temperatures as heat waves. Therefore, we excluded these communities with mild climates. Our final data set included 43 communities [see Supplemental Material, Table 1 (doi:10.1289/ehp.1002313)].
Identification and characterization of heat waves. We first identified all heat waves in each community for 1987–2005 using the community-specific heat wave definition. We characterized each heat wave by its intensity, duration, and timing in season. Heat wave intensity measured average Tmean during the heat wave [other metrics for heat wave intensity were considered in sensitivity analysis; see Supplemental Material, Table 2 (doi:10.1289/ehp.1002313)]. Heat wave duration measured the heat wave’s length in days. We characterized the timing of the heat wave in the summer in two ways. First, timing in season measured the day in the season when the heat wave started (with 1 May = 0, 2 May = 1, etc.). Second, first in season identified whether the heat wave was the first heat wave of its year. Supplemental Material, Table 3 (doi:10.1289/ehp.1002313), gives an example of this heat wave classification.
Association between heat waves and mortality. For each community, we estimated the increase in nonaccidental mortality risk during each heat wave compared with non-heat wave days, controlling for daily temperature. Several studies found that mortality risk increases on individual days of heat (e.g., Anderson and Bell 2009; Baccini et al. 2008). Hajat et al. (2006) discussed the concept of an added heat wave effect and evaluated whether heat wave days affected mortality risk differently than nonconsecutive individual days of high temperatures. This effect has been used to quantify the effects of single notable heat waves [e.g., the 2003 French heat wave (Le Tertre et al. 2006), the 1995 Chicago heat wave (Kaiser et al. 2007)] and to quantify effects of all heat waves over a study period (Hajat et al. 2006; Rocklov and Forsberg 2008).
We estimated this added heat wave effect for each heat wave using community-specific generalized linear models. We controlled for daily maximum temperature to separate effects of heat waves from effects of single days of hot temperature; we also controlled for day of the week and adjusted dew point temperature and time trends to account for seasonal and long-term changes in mortality patterns in a community. We used a nonordered categorical factor to identify heat waves. This variable took a different value for each heat wave. This approach is similar to methods used in earlier studies to compare mortality risk on heat wave days with non-heat wave days (Anderson and Bell 2009; Hajat et al. 2006); however, our model extends the earlier method by allowing risk of mortality to differ by heat wave. Because we estimate a separate effect for each heat wave, we can investigate effect modification by heat wave characteristics (e.g., duration). The model can be stated as
log(µct) = δ0 + ac HWt + yc DOWt + ns(timet,df) + ns(Tct,3) + ns(Dct,2), 
where µct = expected mortality rate for community c on day t; δ0 = model intercept; ac = vector of regression coefficients for heat waves for community c (one per heat wave); HWt = 0 if day t is a non-heat wave day, 1 if day t is the first day of any heat wave, 2 if day t is the second or later day in the first heat wave in the community, 3 if day t is the second or later day in the second heat wave in the community, and so forth; yc = vector of regression coefficients for day of the week for community c; DOWt = categorical variable for day of the week; ns(timet) = natural cubic spline of time, with 3 degrees of freedom (df) per warm season (1 May–30 September); ns(Tct) = natural cubic spline of maximum temperature for community c for day t (df = 3 with knots at quantiles); and (Dct) = natural cubic spline of adjusted dew point temperature for community c on day t (df = 2).
Equation 1 estimates a separate mortality effect for each heat wave in a community. We used a community-specific Bayesian hierarchical model to generate an overall heat wave effect for each community by combining effects of individual heat waves within that community, incorporating the estimates’ variance (Everson and Morris 2000; Kass and Wasserman 1996):
β^h | βh, v^h ~ N(βh, v^h), h = 1,…,n 
β^h | µ, τ2~ N(µ, τ2), 
where β^h = estimated effect of heat wave h on mortality, βh = true effect of heat wave h on mortality, v^h = statistical variance of β^h, µ = true average heat wave effect across all heat waves, τ2 = between-heat wave variance of the true effect, and n = number of heat waves.
This model was fit separately for each community. This method is often used to combine effect estimates across communities in air pollution and temperature studies (Anderson and Bell 2009; Bell and Dominici 2008). National and regional heat wave effects were estimated using similar multistage hierarchical Bayesian models. Results were generated separately for three U.S. regions, Northeast, Midwest, and South, based on regions used previously (Anderson and Bell 2009; Barnett 2007). Insufficient numbers of communities precluded estimates for other regions.
Association between heat wave characteristics and heat wave mortality risk. Within each community, we estimated the relationship between each heat wave characteristic (i.e., intensity, duration, or timing in season) and heat wave effects using a hierarchical Bayesian model, with the heat wave characteristic as an independent variable:
β^h | α0, α1,j, τ2 ~ N[α0 + α1,j (xhj – x–j), τ2], 
where xhj = heat wave characteristic j (intensity, duration, or timing) for heat wave h, x–j = mean characteristic j across all heat waves, α0 = average ln(relative rate) when xhj = x–j, α1,j = change in ln(relative rate) for unit increase in xhj – x–j, and τ2 = variance of heat wave effects. We repeated this model separately for each heat wave characteristic and community.
Sensitivity analysis and extreme events analysis. Use of different heat wave definitions can change the days identified as heat waves [see Supplemental Material, Figure 1 (doi:10.1289/ehp.1002313)]. As a sensitivity analysis, we recalculated main results using different heat wave definitions. Similarly, we investigated effect modification using a variety of metrics for heat wave intensity.
Heat wave characteristics in 43 individual communities (1987–2005). Each horizontal line represents one community, and the length of each line indicates the range of each heat wave characteristic in that community. (A) Intensity of each individual heat wave within a community (tick marks within blue bars). (B) Number of heat waves according to duration (shading) by community. By definition, all heat waves lasted ≥ 2 days. (C) Heat wave timing in season by community (tick marks, individual heat waves).
Some heat waves have had alarming health effects. For example, > 3,000 excess deaths occurred in France during a 2003 heat wave (Le Tertre et al. 2006). Previous researchers hypothesized that a heat wave might have a larger effect if it is more intense or longer or occurs at the beginning of summer (Ellis et al. 1975; Schuman 1972). We investigated whether these characteristics could explain the catastrophic health effects of certain heat waves.
We defined a catastrophic heat wave as one associated with a mortality effect estimate at least three times larger than that of any other heat wave in the same community during our study period. Only a few communities in our study experienced a catastrophic heat wave during our study period. (However, this does not mean that the other communities cannot or will not experience similarly devastating heat waves.) For each community that experienced a catastrophic heat wave, we created a multivariate Bayesian hierarchical model for heat wave effects using 18 years of data (all years except the year of the catastrophic heat wave) with terms for heat wave intensity, duration, and timing in season. We then estimated the mortality effect for the catastrophic heat wave based on this model and compared results with the actual mortality effect.
Characteristics of heat waves. Supplemental Material, Figure 2 (doi:10.1289/ehp.1002313), maps the communities included in this study. Under our heat wave definition (≥ 2 consecutive days with daily mean temperature, Tmean, higher than the community’s 95th percentile summertime Tmean), communities in the study experienced on average 1.9 heat waves/year, with little variation by region (Table 1). Heat waves varied across regions in intensity, duration, and timing in season (Figure 1). Longer and more intense heat waves were more common in the U.S. South, although heat wave characteristics showed wide ranges within each community (Figure 1, Table 1). Most identified heat waves were 2–3 days; heat waves > 7 days were rare in the North and Midwest, and heat waves > 10 days were rare in any community (Figure 1B). Early or late heat waves (i.e., in May or September) were rare (Figure 1C). In most communities, more intense heat waves were also likely to be longer and earlier in the season, although the three heat wave characteristics were not highly correlated [see Supplemental Material, Table 4 (doi:10.1289/ehp.1002313)].
Heat wave characteristics and heat wave effects in 43 communities (1987–2005): associations between heat wave effects (percent mortality increase during the heat wave vs. non-heat wave days) and average Tmean during each heat wave (A), heat wave duration (B), and timing in season of the heat wave (C). Maps show relative risks of nonaccidental mortality during heat wave days compared with non-heat wave days (controlling for daily temperature) and heat wave characteristics. On the map, the color of each community’s circle reflects the magnitude of effect modification; the size reflects the statistical variance, with larger circles indicating more precise estimates. Graph insets plot the value of each heat wave characteristic versus its nonaccidental mortality effect [estimated as an added heat wave effect (Hajat et al. 2006)] for the 10 most populous communities. For these graphs, each circle represents an individual heat wave, and the circle’s color reflects the variance of the mortality effect. The July 1995 Chicago heat wave and August 1988 Minneapolis/St. Paul heat wave are omitted as they are outside the range of the figures. Scales on x-axes differ among the graphs for individual cities.
Association between heat waves and mortality. We found, on average, higher risk of mortality during heat waves than during non-heat wave periods, with variation in health effects of different heat waves (Table 2). Effect estimates were much lower in the South than in the Northeast or Midwest (Table 2), although the threshold temperatures used to define heat waves (95th percentile of warm season daily Tmean) were higher in the South [see Supplemental Material, Figure 2 (doi:10.1289/ehp.1002313)]. Some southern cities (e.g., Charlotte, NC; Dallas/Fort Worth, TX; Oklahoma City, OK; Tulsa, OK) showed no mortality increase during heat waves.
Impact of heat wave characteristics on mortality risk. The health effects of individual heat waves were associated with heat wave intensity, duration, and timing in many of the communities, with large heterogeneity across communities. Figure 2 shows community-specific plots of heat wave effects versus heat wave characteristics for the 10 most populous communities and maps of the overall association in each community. In general, all three heat wave characteristics were more strongly associated with heat wave effects in the Northeast and Midwest than in the South (Figure 2, Table 3). A 1°F increase in average Tmean during a heat wave was associated with a 4.39% increase in the relative risk of mortality during that heat wave in the Northeast and a 3.22% increase in the Midwest. The association between heat wave duration and mortality effects was largest in the Northeast, where mortality risk during a heat wave was on average 2.50% higher for every extra day a heat wave lasted.
We divided heat waves into two groups: those that were the first to occur in a year (first in season) and those that were preceded by another heat wave in their year (not first in season) for a given year and community. On average, we categorized 40% of all heat waves as first in season. First-in-season heat waves generally had higher effects than did later heat waves, although effects were similar in the Midwest (Table 4). The importance of timing in the season on heat wave effects was also evident when we considered the influence of day in season (i.e., which day of the season the heat wave started) on heat wave effects, particularly in the Northeast (Figure 2C, Table 3).
Sensitivity analysis. We reestimated mortality risk during heat waves compared with non-heat wave days using different heat wave definitions [see Supplemental Material, Tables 2 and 5 (doi:10.1289/ehp.1002313)]. Point estimates changed but trends were similar under all definitions considered: Average heat wave effects were positive and significant, more intense and longer heat waves were positively associated with heat wave effects, and the first heat waves in the summer almost always had a higher average effect than later heat waves. Heat wave intensity was significantly associated with heat wave effects for almost all heat wave definitions [see Supplemental Material, Table 5 (doi:10.1289/ehp.1002313)]. Regional trends were largely consistent regardless of heat wave definition, with higher, more significant heat wave effects in the Northeast than in other areas and a stronger association between heat wave intensity and heat wave effects in the Northeast (data not shown).
We tested effect modification by heat wave intensity using several different metrics for intensity [see Supplemental Material, Tables 2 and 7 (doi:10.1289/ehp.1002313)]. For each temperature metric, we considered the effect of the peak value (the highest value of that metric during a single day of the heat wave) and the average value across all days of the heat wave. Metrics of heat wave intensity were not all strongly correlated across communities [see Supplemental Material, Table 6 (doi:10.1289/ehp.1002313)], although intensity measures based on the peak value of a particular temperature metric and the average value of the same temperature metric were highly correlated (0.87–0.93). Supplemental Material, Table 7 (doi:10.1289/ehp.1002313), shows the percent increase in mortality risk for heat wave days compared with non-heat wave days for a 1°F increase in heat wave intensity, under different heat wave intensity definitions. More intense (i.e., higher temperature) heat waves were associated with higher mortality risk under all definitions of heat wave intensity.
Analysis of extreme heat waves. In a separate analysis, we analyzed effects of particularly extreme heat waves. We identified two catastrophic heat waves; both involved the same weather system: 12–16 July 1995 in Chicago and 13–15 July 1995 in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Both heat waves were the most intense in their community over the study period (average Tmean = 87.2°F for Chicago, 87.7°F for Milwaukee) [see Supplemental Material, Figure 3 (doi:10.1289/ehp.1002313)]. They were not extreme in duration or timing in the summer (both were in July, and they lasted 5 and 3 days, respectively). Mortality risks during these heat waves, compared with non-heat wave days (using Equation 1), were 133.9% [95% posterior interval (PI), 116.9–152.2%] for Chicago and 93.0% (95% PI, 53.1–143.3%) for Milwaukee.
We investigated whether the mortality risk of these two events could be explained by their intensity, duration, and timing in season. We fitted multivariate community-specific models separately for Chicago and Milwaukee, excluding heat waves during the year of the catastrophic heat wave (1995). We then used these two models to estimate the expected mortality risk from the two catastrophic heat waves and found an increase in mortality risk of 18.9% for the Chicago catastrophic heat wave and 10.3% for Milwaukee, much smaller than the mortality risks observed.
Within-community heterogeneity in heat wave effects. Estimated overall heat wave effects were similar to those calculated in an earlier study of U.S. heat waves that included more communities over a shorter time period (1987–2000); however, that previous study did not investigate variation in effects of individual heat waves within a community or explore how heat wave characteristics modify mortality risk (Anderson and Bell 2009). We found that, within a community, heat wave mortality effects are influenced by the heat wave’s intensity, duration, and timing in the season. This effect modification probably results from physiological responses to heat and/or behavior modification.
When ambient temperature is high, the human body responds via thermoregulation: Blood vessels dilate near the skin to transfer heat from the body’s core to the skin, and then sweat transfers heat from the skin by evaporation (Havenith 2005). Even when body temperature remains normal, thermoregulation strains the cardiovascular system (Havenith 2005). The higher the temperature or the longer the heat wave, the more work required of the cardiovascular system to maintain normal temperature; therefore, more intense or longer heat waves are likely to have greater health effects.
Heat wave timing in the season might influence mortality risk from a) deaths of particularly susceptible individuals during heat waves or single hot days earlier in the summer, leaving a smaller pool of susceptible individuals later in the summer (mortality displacement), or b) acclimatization of individuals to heat over the course of a summer. Evidence of both effects exists: studies considering health effects of both single days of heat (Baccini et al. 2008; Braga et al. 2001; Hajat et al. 2005) and of specific heat waves (Kaiser et al. 2007; Le Tertre et al. 2006) found evidence of mortality displacement, whereas experimental studies found that humans acclimatize to heat, usually within several weeks of exposure (Bouchama and Knochel 2002). We found that heat waves earlier in summer had higher mortality risk than did later heat waves and that the first heat wave of the summer had a higher impact than did later heat waves. Additional research is needed to determine whether the lessening impact of heat waves over the summer is due to mortality displacement, biological adaptation (e.g., persons becoming physically accustomed to higher temperatures), and/or behavior modification [e.g., increased use of air conditioning (AC), staying indoors]. Additional research could also investigate if the timing of heat waves has a nonlinear relationship with mortality effects.
The characteristics of heat waves considered here (intensity, duration, and timing in season) could not fully explain variation in heat wave effects; for example, often heat waves of the same intensity or length affected mortality very differently within a community. Other possible sources of variation in heat wave mortality risk within a community include changes over time in communities’ responses to heat waves (e.g., implementation of heat wave warning systems) and changes in public perception of heat waves (e.g., willingness to take protective measures) (Kalkstein et al. 1996; Kovats and Ebi 2006). Power outages sometimes occur during heat waves (e.g., Bridger et al. 1976; Luber and McGeehin 2008), and these could contribute to particularly high impacts due to increased heat exposure without AC and greater difficulty leaving upper-level apartments in buildings with elevators. Often studies cite the differences between the effects of two heat waves as evidence of improvements in community response (e.g., Palecki et al. 2001; Weisskopf et al. 2002). This study shows a large variation in heat wave effects for a variety of reasons, suggesting that studies analyzing the efficacy of response measures should not rely on differences between only two heat waves or ignore differences in heat wave characteristics.
Between-community heterogeneity in heat wave effects and effect modification. Heterogeneity between communities in both heat wave effects and effect modification by heat wave characteristics might result from a) physical acclimatization of residents of warmer communities, b) different levels of exposure in different communities (e.g., AC use, housing structure, clothing type), c) different community-level responses to extreme heat (e.g., heat wave warning systems), d) different demographics (e.g., population in high risk categories such as the elderly or less healthy), or e) different geographical, meteorological, or pollution factors within communities that might confound or modify temperature–mortality relationships.
We observed general regional patterns in community-level heat wave effects that are consistent with other studies of heat waves or high temperature, which report highest effects in the U.S. Northeast and Midwest (e.g., Anderson and Bell 2009; Braga et al. 2001). Some researchers found that temperature effects were related to AC (e.g., Braga et al. 2001; O’Neill et al. 2005), although an early study noted similar geographic patterns before widespread AC prevalence (Gover 1938). In contrast, patterns are reversed in Europe, where communities with warmer climates generally had larger heat effects (Baccini et al. 2008).
Heterogeneity in effect modification by heat wave characteristics followed similar regional patterns. Heat wave intensity, duration, and timing in the summer had smaller effects on mortality in the South than elsewhere. Differences between the South and other parts of the country in exposure to outdoor air temperature (e.g., because of AC use) might explain why even very long and intense heat waves failed to affect mortality in some communities.
Sensitivity analysis. Different studies have used a variety of definitions to select what days constitute “heat waves.” Additionally, a variety of theories exist concerning which temperature metric should be used to best capture the heat wave periods most dangerous to human health. Some researchers propose that high minimum temperatures might be particularly important, theorizing that the body is more affected with no relief from cool nighttime temperatures (Schwartz 2005). Others suggest the use of apparent temperature, because the body may be more stressed if humidity limits cooling by sweat evaporation (Robinson 2001). This question is complex, and the appropriate metric may vary by individual, depending on health status and exposure. For example, minimum temperature might be important for someone without AC but a less valuable metric for someone living in a home with central AC. We performed sensitivity analysis under a variety of heat wave definitions (intensity, duration, metric) to aid interpretation and meaningful comparison with other studies.
We did not control for air pollution in our model, because earlier research showed that temperature effects in the United States were robust to air pollution (Anderson and Bell 2009). However, air pollution and temperature might act synergistically during heat waves; future research could investigate this question.
Extreme heat waves. Several days early in July 1995 qualified as a heat wave in many of the Midwest and Northeast communities in our study; mortality effects were particularly extreme in Chicago and Milwaukee. The July 1995 heat wave was unusual in this data set in terms of the magnitude of mortality effects, although it was not particularly long or early in the season. We found that the extremity of this heat wave’s effects could partially be explained by its intensity, although comparison is difficult because the heat wave is outside the range of other heat waves in terms of intensity and mortality. Although we found heat wave mortality risk to be affected by intensity, duration, and timing in season, these factors could not fully explain catastrophic heat wave effects. Some variation may relate to changes from summer to summer in the number of people in a community who are very susceptible to heat. For example, one study found that heat-related mortality can be affected by rates of influenza-related mortality the preceding winter (Rocklov et al. 2009). Other factors, possibly social, may also play a role. Such factors, including changes in community and public health responses to heat, are beyond the scope of this study and could be explored in future research. The finding that catastrophic heat wave effects cannot be adequately explained by heat wave intensity, duration, and timing in the summer highlights the difficulty of predicting catastrophic heat waves, either with heat warning systems or with long-term climate change projections.
A meteorologic study showed that heat waves of similar intensity to the July 1995 heat wave are very rare in Chicago, although not unprecedented in the 20th century (Kunkel et al. 1996). Earlier studies of individual heat waves in the United States used different methods to estimate excess mortality but showed that mortality effects as high as those observed in Chicago and Milwaukee in July 1995 have occurred. Estimated approximate mortality increases during other extreme heat wave periods, compared with non-heat wave periods, for Los Angeles, California, are 109% in late September 1939 and 112% in early September 1955 (Oechsli and Buechley 1970); for St. Louis, Missouri, are 91% in July 1966 (Bridger et al. 1976) and 159% in 9–14 July 1966 (Henschel et al. 1969); and for New York, New York, are 113% in 28 August through 3 September 1948 (Ellis and Nelson 1978).
Study of heat waves’ effects on human health is important for the present day and central to estimating the impacts of climate change. Heat waves are anticipated to be more common, longer, and more intense in the future (Meehl and Tebaldi 2004). This study is unique among heat wave studies in its national scale, long time frame, multiple heat wave definitions, and consideration of how heat wave mortality effects are associated with heat wave intensity, duration, and timing in the season. We found that mortality risk increased during prolonged periods of extreme heat, compared with the community’s usual climate, and estimated how this mortality risk was affected by heat wave intensity, duration, or timing within the year. Because of the national scale, we were able to examine regional trends and observed both larger heat wave effects and greater effect modification by heat wave characteristics in certain regions, particularly the Northeast; trends were less defined or in some cases inversed in some communities in the South. Heat wave–related mortality under a changing climate will need to address acclimatization over a long time frame (e.g., changes over years) and a shorter time frame (e.g., changes within a summer). Additionally, the observed heterogeneity, both in heat wave effects and in the influence of heat wave characteristics on mortality effects between different communities, indicates the importance of developing heat wave response plans that are community specific.
- Anderson BG, Bell ML. 2009. Weather-related mortality: how heat, cold, and heat waves affect mortality in the United States. Epidemiology 20(2):205–213.
- Baccini M, Biggeri A, Accetta G, Kosatsky T, Katsouyanni K, Analitis A, et al. 2008. Heat effects on mortality in 15 European cities. Epidemiology 19(5):711–719.
- Barnett AG. 2007. Temperature and cardiovascular deaths in the US elderly: changes over time. Epidemiology 18(3):369–372.
- Bell ML, Dominici F. 2008. Effect modification by community characteristics on the short-term effects of ozone exposure and mortality in 98 US communities. Am J Epidemiol 167(8):986–997.
- Bell ML, McDermott A, Zeger SL, Samet JM, Dominici F. 2004. Ozone and short-term mortality in 95 US urban communities, 1987–2000. JAMA 292(19):2372–2378.
- Bosen JF. 1958. An approximation formula to compute relative humidity from dry bulb and dew point temperatures. Mon Weather Rev 86(12):486.
- Bouchama A, Knochel JP. 2002. Heat stroke. N Engl J Med 346(25):1978–1988.
- Braga AL, Zanobetti A, Schwartz J. 2001. The time course of weather-related deaths. Epidemiology 12(6):662–667.
- Bridger CA, Ellis FP, Taylor HL. 1976. Mortality in St. Louis, Missouri, during heat waves in 1936, 1953, 1954, 1955, and 1966. Environ Res 12(1):38–48.
- Diaz J, Jordan A, Garcia R, Lopez C, Alberdi JC, Hernandez E, et al. 2002. Heat waves in Madrid 1986–1997: effects on the health of the elderly. Int Arch Occup Environ Health 75(3):163–170.
- Dominici F, Peng RD, Bell ML, Pham L, McDermott A, Zeger SL, et al. 2006. Fine particulate air pollution and hospital admission for cardiovascular and respiratory diseases. JAMA 295(10):1127–1134.
- Ellis FP, Nelson F. 1978. Mortality in the elderly in a heat wave in New York City, August 1975. Environ Res 15(3):504–512.
- Ellis FP, Nelson F, Pincus L. 1975. Mortality during heat waves in New York City July, 1972 and August and September, 1973. Environ Res 10(1):1–13.
- Everson PJ, Morris CN. 2000. Inference for multivariate normal hierarchical models. J R Stat Soc Series B Stat Methodol 62:399–412.
- Gover M.. 1938. Mortality during periods of excessive temperature. Public Health Rep 53:1122–1143.
- Hajat S, Armstrong B, Baccini M, Biggeri A, Bisanti L, Russo A, et al. 2006. Impact of high temperatures on mortality: is there an added heat wave effect? Epidemiology 17(6):632–638.
- Hajat S, Armstrong BG, Gouveia N, Wilkinson P. 2005. Mortality displacement of heat-related deaths: a comparison of Delhi, Sao Paulo, and London. Epidemiology 16(5):613–620.
- Hajat S, Kovats RS, Atkinson RW, Haines A. 2002. Impact of hot temperatures on death in London: a time series approach. J Epidemiol Community Health 56(5):367–372.
- Havenith G. 2005. Temperature regulation, heat balance, and climatic stress. In: Extreme Weather Events and Public Health Responses (Kirch W, Bertollini R, Menne B, eds). Berlin:Springer. pp. 69–80.
- Henschel A, Burton LL, Margolies L, Smith JE. 1969. An analysis of the heat deaths in St. Louis during July, 1966. Am J Public Health Nations Health 59(12):2232–2242.
- Internet-based Health and Air Pollution Surveillance System (iHAPPS) 2005. Mortality, Air Pollution, and Meteorological Data for 108 US Cities 1987–2000. Available: http://www.ihapss.jhsph.edu/data/NMMAPS/Data/data_download_gz.htm [accessed 5 October 2010]
- Kaiser R, Le Tertre A, Schwartz J, Gotway CA, Daley WR, Rubin CH. 2007. The effect of the 1995 heat wave in Chicago on all-cause and cause-specific mortality. Am J Public Health 97: suppl 1S158–S162.
- Kalkstein LS, Greene JS. 1996. Quantitative analysis of summer air masses in the eastern United States and an application to human mortality. Clim Res 7:43–53.
- Kalkstein LS, Jamason PF, Greene JS, Libby J, Robinson L. 1996. The Philadelphia hot weather-health watch/warning system: development and application, summer 1995. Bull Am Meteorol Soc 77(7):1519–1528.
- Kalkstein LS, Smoyer KE. 1993. The impact of climate change on human health: some international implications. Experientia 49(11):969–979.
- Kass RE, Wasserman L. 1996. The selection of prior distributions by formal rules. J Am Stat Assoc 91:1343–1370.
- Kovats RS, Ebi KL. 2006. Heatwaves and public health in Europe. Eur J Public Health 16(6):592–599.
- Kunkel KE, Changnon SA, Reinke BC, Arritt RW. 1996. The July 1995 heat wave in the Midwest: a climatic perspective and critical weather factors. Bull Am Meteorol Soc. 77. (7):pp. 1507–1518.
- Le Tertre A, Lefranc A, Eilstein D, Declercq C, Medina S, Blanchard M, et al. 2006. Impact of the 2003 heatwave on all-cause mortality in 9 French cities. Epidemiology 17(1):75–79.
- Luber G, McGeehin M.. 2008. Climate change and extreme heat events. Am J Prev Med 35(5):429–435.
- Marmor M.. 1975. Heat wave mortality in New York City, 1949 to 1970. Arch Environ Health 30(3):130–136.
- Meehl GA, Tebaldi C. 2004. More intense, more frequent, and longer lasting heat waves in the 21st century. Science 305(5686):994–997.
- National Climatic Data Center 2011. Global Summary of the Day. Available: http://www7.ncdc.noaa.gov/CDO/cdoselect.cmd?datasetabbv=GSOD&countryabbv=&georegionabbv= [accessed 6 January 2011]
- Oechsli FW, Buechley RW. 1970. Excess mortality associated with three Los Angeles September hot spells. Environ Res 3(4):277–284.
- O’Neill MS, Zanobetti A, Schwartz J. 2005. Disparities by race in heat-related mortality in four US cities: the role of air conditioning prevalence. J Urban Health 82(2):191–197.
- Palecki MA, Changnon A, Kunkel KE. 2001. The nature and impacts of the July 1999 heat wave in the midwestern United States: learning from the lessons of 1995. Bull Am Meteorol Soc. 82. (7):pp. 1353–1367.
- Peng RD, Chang HH, Bell ML, McDermott A, Zeger SL, Samet JM, et al. 2008. Coarse particulate matter air pollution and hospital admissions for cardiovascular and respiratory diseases among Medicare patients. JAMA 299(18):2172–2179.
- Robinson PJ. 2001. On the definition of a heat wave. J Appl Meteorol 40:762–775.
- Rocklov J, Forsberg B.. 2008. The effect of temperature on mortality in Stockholm 1998–2003: a study of lag structures and heatwave effects. Scand J Public Health 36:516–523.
- Rocklov J, Forsberg B, Meister K.. 2009. Winter mortality modifies the heat-mortality association the following summer. Eur Respir J 33(2):245–251.
- Schuman SH. 1972. Patterns of urban heat-wave deaths and implications for prevention: data from New York and St. Louis during July, 1966. Environ Res 5(1):59–75.
- Schwartz J.. 2005. Who is sensitive to extremes of temperature? A case-only analysis. Epidemiology 16(1):67–72.
- Semenza JC, Rubin CH, Falter KH, Selanikio JD, Flanders WD, Howe HL, et al. 1996. Heat-related deaths during the July 1995 heat wave in Chicago. N Engl J Med 335(2):84–90.
- Smoyer KE. 1998. A comparative analysis of heat waves and associated mortality in St. Louis, Missouri—1980 and 1995. Int J Biometeorol 42(1):44–50.
- Weisskopf MG, Anderson HA, Foldy S, Hanrahan LP, Blair K, Torok TJ, et al. 2002. Heat wave morbidity and mortality, Milwaukee, Wis, 1999 vs 1995: an improved response? Am J Public Health 92(5):830–833.
- Whitman S, Good G, Donoghue ER, Benbow N, Shou W, Mou S. 1997. Mortality in Chicago attributed to the July 1995 heat wave. Am J Public Health 87(9):1515–1518.
CEHN December 2014 Article of the Month
“The Navigation Guide—Evidence-Based Medicine Meets Environmental Health: Integration of Animal and Human Evidence for PFOA Effects on Fetal Growth” (Environ Health Perspect; DOI:10.1289/ehp.1307923) has been selected by the Children’s Environmental Health Network (CEHN) as its December 2014 Article of the Month. These CEHN summaries discuss the potential policy implications of current children’s environmental health research.
Introducing Children’s Health Collection 2014
EHP’s fifth annual Children’s Health Collection is now available. The collection comprises abstracts of all relevant articles published in EHP from October 2013 through September 2014: peer-reviewed research articles, news features, Science Selections, and editorials.
ISEE 2014 Abstracts Now Available
EHP is pleased to present the abstracts for the 26th annual conference of the International Society for Environmental Epidemiology (ISEE), From Local to Global: Advancing Science for Policy in Environmental Health, held 24–28 August 2014 in Seattle, Washington.
Sign Up to Receive E-mail Alerts
Recent Advance Publications
Comparative Effects of Di(n-Butyl) Phthalate Exposure on Fetal Germ Cell Development in the Rat and in Human Fetal Testis Xenografts
Interaction Effects of Temperature and Ozone on Lung Function and Markers of Systemic Inflammation, Coagulation, and Fibrinolysis: A Crossover Study of Healthy Young Volunteers
First Steps toward Harmonized Human Biomonitoring in Europe: Demonstration Project to Perform Human Biomonitoring on a European Scale
Children’s Health in Latin America: The Influence of Environmental Exposures
Global Analysis of Posttranscriptional Gene Expression in Response to Sodium Arsenite