Three Criteria for Ecological Fallacy
Alvaro J. Idrovo
Center for Health Systems Research, National Institute of Public Health, Cuernavaca, Morelos, Mexico, E-mail: email@example.com
Environ Health Perspect 119:a332-a332 (2011). http://dx.doi.org/10.1289/ehp.1103768 [online 01 August 2011]
The author declares that he has no competing financial interests.
In a large cohort study published in Environmental Health Perspectives, Brenner et al. (2011) confirmed previous results on I-131 exposure and thyroid cancer among a Ukranian population. According to the authors, one motivation to study this association was based on evidence from ecological studies (Jacob et al. 1999) with two methodological limitations: use of grouped doses and poor control of confounding. With these new findings, evidence from ecological, case–control, and cohort studies are consistent; thus, an interesting question is whether there was an ecological fallacy.
Although ecological studies are important to epidemiology (especially in environmental and social epidemiology), public health practitioners seem afraid of ecological studies. It is a common practice to assume the presence of ecological fallacy (Robinson 1950) and low-level validity when analyzing an ecological study. Most epidemiologists prefer an exclusive individualistic approach, although the importance of a multilevel causal approach is widely recognized (Diez-Roux 2002). In this sense, some authors suggest that it is as important to recognize the presence of ecological fallacy as to recognize psychologistic or individualistic fallacy (Subramanian et al. 2009) (Figure 1).
Thus, it is necessary to have clear guidelines on when there is or not an ecological fallacy. In this sense, I propose three criteria for the identification of ecological fallacy; all three of these should be present to confirm its existence:
- Results must be obtained with ecological (population) data.
- Data must be inferred to individuals. One use of ecological studies is to explore individual-level association when individual data are not available. When the focus of the study was contextual or based on population effects and there is no inference to individuals, ecological fallacy is not possible. When only the first two criteria are present—which is insufficient to affirm ecological fallacy—it is appropriate to acknowledge that there is a possible relationship and that further study is required.
- Results obtained with individual data are contradictory.
Only when empirical data are available is it possible to confirm that an ecological fallacy is present.
Related EHP Articles
- Brenner AV, Tronko MD, Hatch M, Bogdanova TI, Oliynik VA, Lubin JH, et al. 2011. I-131 dose response for incident thyroid cancers in Ukraine related to the Chornobyl accident. Environ Health Perspect 119:933–939.; doi:10.1289/ehp.1002674 [Online 17 March 2011]
- Diez-Roux AV. 2002. A glossary for multilevel analysis. J Epidemiol Community Health 56(8):588–594.
- Jacob P, Kenigsberg Y, Zvonova I, Goulko G, Buglova E, Heidenreich WF, et al. 1999. Childhood exposure due to the Chernobyl accident and thyroid cancer risk in contaminated areas of Belarus and Russia. Br J Cancer 80(9):1461–1469.
- Robinson WS. 1950. Ecological correlations and the behavior of individuals. Am Sociol Rev 15(3):351–357.
- Subramanian SV, Jones K, Kaddour A, Krieger N. 2009. Revisiting Robinson: the perils of individualistic and ecologic fallacy. Int J Epidemiol 38(2):342–360.
My Journal Shelf
EHP is now available on My Journal Shelf, a pilot project of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) to provide quick access to current issues of scientific journals. Learn more about My Journal Shelf from NIAID.
EHP is proud to announce its 2013 Paper of the Year is “450K Epigenome-Wide Scan Identifies Differential DNA Methylation in Newborns Related to Maternal Smoking during Pregnancy” [Environ Health Perspect 120(10):1425–1431 (2012); doi:10.1289/ehp.1205412]. The Paper of the Year award is given to the most highly cited Research Article, Commentary, or Review Article published in the preceding 12 months.
Congratulations to authors Bonnie R. Joubert, Siri E. Håberg, Roy M. Nilsen, Xuting Wang, Stein E. Vollset, Susan K. Murphy, Zhiqing Huang, Cathrine Hoyo, Øivind Midttun, Lea A. Cupul-Uicab, Per M. Ueland, Michael C. Wu, Wenche Nystad, Douglas A. Bell, Shyamal D. Peddada, and Stephanie J. London.
Children’s Health Collection 2013 is now available for browsing and downloading. The collection includes everything we've published on children's health from October 2012 through September 2013—you'll find abstracts of peer-reviewed research articles, reviews, and commentaries, plus quick links to relevant news articles, editorials, and podcasts.
Environment and Health—
Bridging South, North, East and West
Basel, Switzerland 19–23 August 2013
Sign Up to Receive E-mail Alerts
Recent Advance Publications
- Within- and Between-Child Variation in Repeated Urinary Pesticide Metabolite Measurements over a 1-Year Period
- Diethylstilbestrol (DES)-Stimulated Hormonal Toxicity is Mediated by ERα Alteration of Target Gene Methylation Patterns and Epigenetic Modifiers (DNMT3A, MBD2, and HDAC2) in the Mouse Seminal Vesicle
- Anogenital Distance and Penile Length in Infants with Hypospadias or Cryptorchidism: Comparison with Normative Data
- DNA Methylation in Oocytes and Liver of Female Mice and Their Offspring: Effects of High-Fat-Diet–Induced Obesity
- Environmental Noise Pollution in the United States: Developing an Effective Public Health Response
- Enablers and Barriers to Large-Scale Uptake of Improved Solid Fuel Stoves: A Systematic Review
- Breastfeeding: A Potential Excretion Route for Mothers and Implications for Infant Exposure to Perfluoroalkyl Acids
- EHPNoonNews: HudsonValleyNews—Concerns over fracking waste as deicer http:// http://t.co/NVGSQzlrjK Watch for related coverage in EHP News
- EHPNoonNews: FoxNews—Mouse study suggests father's diet may influence offspring health http://t.co/WPGxXHqFRH
- EHPNoonNews: Intelligencer/NewsRegister—WV health dept concerned about benzene emissions near gas drilling sites http://t.co/R68NgQk6tk
- EHPNoonNews: EFSA releases first full risk assessment of aspartame http://t.co/EL6BjLn2oL
- AdvPubl: Within-child variability in pesticide metabolites http://t.co/e5dtYpGMHz